A useful annual review should answer one question: does the banking setup still fit the way the business operates today? The answer should come from transaction evidence, staff access, real costs and failure scenarios, not from a generic feature list.
Start with twelve months of evidence, not memory
Pull the last twelve months of account activity and summarise the patterns that matter. Count incoming payments, supplier transfers, payroll runs, card transactions, cash deposits, international payments, returned items, urgent payments and support cases. Note how often the team had to work around the bank rather than through it. That may mean downloading data manually, asking the owner to approve routine payments or moving money through a second account because a limit was too low.
Then compare those facts with the assumptions made when the account was opened. A company that expected ten payments a month may now make 200. A founder-only account may now support a finance assistant and an external bookkeeper. A domestic business may now pay suppliers in euros or dollars. The review should identify where the banking arrangement has drifted away from the actual operating model.
Recalculate the total banking cost using real activity
Do not review cost by looking only at the monthly account fee. Add transaction charges, cash or cheque costs, foreign exchange, card charges, borrowing costs and software expenses created by the banking process. Include internal administration where the setup forces manual work. The aim is to compare the annual cost of operating the account, not the price shown in an advertisement.
A simple example shows why. Suppose a business pays £12 per month for an account, £20 per month in transaction charges and spends two staff hours each month fixing exports and reconciliation. At £30 per staff hour, the real annual cost is about £1,104: £144 account fee, £240 transaction charges and £720 of staff time. A nominally more expensive account could be cheaper overall if it removes most of that administration.
Review every user, card, permission and approval path
List every person who can view balances, create payments, approve payments, change beneficiaries, order cards or alter account settings. Remove leavers and obsolete access. Check whether bookkeepers and accountants have the minimum access needed rather than owner-level permissions. If several people can spend, confirm card limits and approval rules still match their roles.
Then test separation of duties. In a growing company, the same person should not automatically be able to create a new beneficiary, enter a large payment and approve it without any review. The right control depends on business size and risk, but the annual review is the moment to confirm that access has evolved with staffing. Also check recovery arrangements. If the main administrator loses a phone or is unexpectedly absent, the company should still be able to meet payroll, tax and critical supplier obligations.
Review cash concentration, reserve balances and deposit protection
Look at the highest balance held during the year, not just the balance on review day. If the business regularly accumulates cash for VAT, Corporation Tax, payroll or a property purchase, ask whether too much money is concentrated with one authorised institution. FSCS states that eligible deposits with a UK-authorised bank, building society or credit union are protected up to £120,000 per eligible person, per authorised firm from 1 December 2025, and it generally protects company deposits subject to eligibility rules.
Check banking licences rather than brand names because more than one brand can share the same authorised firm. Then decide whether reserve cash still belongs in the operating account. Money that must remain instantly available is different from genuine surplus cash that may be suitable for an easy-access, notice or fixed-term business savings product. The review should separate liquidity needs from return-seeking cash rather than treating the whole balance as one pot.
Test resilience, service quality and the practical cost of switching
Review the failures that actually occurred: blocked payments, delayed transfers, card problems, lost devices, support delays or bank-feed outages. For each one, ask how long it took to resolve and whether the business had a fallback. A second authorised user, a secondary bank account or an alternative payment route can be valuable if a single failure would otherwise stop payroll or a critical supplier payment.
If the account is now a poor fit, check the switching route before deciding that moving is too difficult. The Current Account Switch Service says eligible businesses can use the service where annual turnover does not exceed £6.5 million and there are fewer than 50 employees. Regular payment arrangements are moved under the service and the guarantee covers errors in the switching process. Existing overdrafts need separate attention because replacement borrowing must be agreed with the new provider.
Write a one-page decision record and set the next review trigger
Finish with a short record stating the current annual banking cost, the main operational strengths, the biggest control weakness and the decision: keep, renegotiate, add a second provider or switch. If you keep the account, note what would cause an earlier review. Useful triggers include a large increase in turnover, hiring finance staff, opening a second entity, starting international trade, taking on borrowing or holding materially larger cash balances.
This record stops the annual review becoming a ritual. It also gives the next reviewer a baseline. If the account was retained because it saved two hours of reconciliation each month, check whether that benefit still exists next year. If the bank was retained because cash deposits were convenient, revisit the decision if cash stops being material. The goal is not annual switching. The goal is making sure the banking structure continues to justify itself.
Editorial Verdict
An annual business bank review is worthwhile when it uses real operating evidence. The most important checks are total cost, staff access, payment authority, resilience, cash concentration and whether the account still matches the company's transaction pattern. A review that only compares monthly fees will miss most of the reasons businesses eventually become frustrated with an account.
Keep the review proportionate. A two-person consultancy does not need a treasury project, but it still needs clean access, reliable payments and a recovery route. A larger company should document stronger controls and concentration risk. If switching is justified, plan the transition before closing anything and verify current eligibility, overdraft arrangements and provider terms directly.
Sources
- Financial Services Compensation Scheme, deposit protection limit: https://protected.fscs.org.uk/what-we-cover/banks-building-societies-credit-unions/deposit-limit/
- Financial Services Compensation Scheme, small business protection: https://protected.fscs.org.uk/making-a-claim/claims-process/small-business/
- Current Account Switch Service, business eligibility and common questions: https://www.currentaccountswitch.co.uk/common-questions-business/
- Current Account Switch Service, business switching process: https://www.currentaccountswitch.co.uk/the-switching-process-business/