A useful comparison does not start with a monthly fee or a list of app features. It starts with the transactions your company makes, the people who need access, the protection behind the provider and the cost of running the account for a full year.
Build a transaction profile before opening comparison tables
Take one normal month and count what actually happens. Record incoming transfers, card settlements, Direct Debits, supplier payments, payroll, cash deposits, international transfers and any cheques. Add the number of people who need access and note which accounting package receives the bank data. This turns a vague search for a "good business account" into a measurable operating requirement.
A consultancy receiving eight client transfers a month may care mainly about simple reconciliation and reliable Faster Payments. A retailer paying in £6,000 of cash each month may care far more about deposit locations and cash handling charges. An ecommerce company can have almost no cash but dozens of marketplace payouts, foreign currency conversions and staff cards. These businesses should not end up with the same shortlist simply because they have similar turnover.
Calculate the full annual cost after introductory offers end
Include the monthly account charge, electronic transaction fees, cash charges, card fees, international payments, foreign exchange, extra user costs and any paid accounting integration. If the provider offers free banking for an introductory period, model both the first year and a normal year afterwards. A decision that looks cheap during a promotion can become expensive once transaction charges start.
Use your real activity. Suppose Account A costs £0 per month but charges 30p for 180 outgoing payments. That is £54 per month before cash, cards or other charges. Account B costs £15 per month and includes those payments. In that simplified example, Account B is £39 per month cheaper despite the visible subscription fee. The arithmetic should reflect the business, not the marketing label "free".
Compare user access, payment authority and recovery routes
As soon as more than one person handles money, permissions matter. Check whether users receive their own credentials, whether one person can prepare a payment and another approve it, whether card limits can differ by employee and whether an accountant can have view or export access without being able to move funds. Shared credentials are convenient until someone leaves or a payment needs to be traced.
Also test account recovery. Imagine the main administrator loses their phone at 3pm on payroll day. Can another authorised user release the payment? Is there telephone support for urgent access issues? Does replacing a device require the director who is abroad? Reliability includes the exception path, not only the app experience when everything is working normally.
Check the legal provider and how the money is protected
A business account can be provided by a bank or by a non-bank payment or e-money institution. These are not the same protection model. FSCS states that eligible deposits at a UK-authorised bank, building society or credit union are protected up to £120,000 per eligible person or entity, per authorised firm from 1 December 2025. It generally protects company deposits, subject to its rules.
The FCA explains that money held with an authorised electronic money institution or authorised payment institution is not protected by FSCS. Instead, relevant funds are protected through safeguarding rules. Safeguarding is important, but the insolvency process can take time and customers may not necessarily receive the same outcome or speed as an eligible FSCS deposit claim. Before comparing brands, identify the legal entity that actually holds or safeguards the money.
Test switching mechanics before you decide the old account is too difficult to leave
If your current account no longer fits, check whether the new provider participates in the Current Account Switch Service. The service says eligible businesses can use it where annual turnover does not exceed £6.5 million and the business has fewer than 50 employees. The service moves regular payment arrangements and provides a guarantee for switching errors, but borrowing such as an overdraft must be agreed separately with the new provider.
Even with a formal switch, plan operationally. Download historic statements, list connected accounting feeds, payment gateways and payroll instructions, check card subscriptions and tell key staff when access will change. Keep enough liquidity to deal with an unexpected delay. A technically successful switch can still cause disruption if the finance team has not mapped the systems around the account.
Use a scorecard based on five jobs, not a universal ranking
Score each shortlisted account against five categories: money in, money out, control, evidence and resilience. Money in covers customer receipts, cash and card settlements. Money out covers supplier payments, payroll and international transfers. Control covers users, approvals and card limits. Evidence covers statements, exports and accounting feeds. Resilience covers support, recovery and a fallback when the main user or payment route is unavailable.
Weight the categories according to your business. A cash-heavy retailer might give cash handling 30 percent of the score, while an international consultancy gives that category almost nothing and gives foreign exchange and international transfers much more weight. This approach avoids a false "best account" conclusion. The strongest account is the one that performs well on the tasks your business actually needs.
Editorial Verdict
Do not compare business bank accounts as if the monthly fee is the product. The product is the whole operating system around receiving money, paying it out, controlling staff access, keeping records and recovering from problems. A cheaper account can be poor value if it adds manual work or makes an important workflow unreliable.
Build a one-month transaction profile, calculate the normal annual cost, identify the legal provider and protection model, then test one difficult scenario before applying. Recheck live fees and eligibility directly because provider terms change. A shortlist is good when every account on it has a clear reason to be there.
Sources
- FSCS, deposit protection limit: https://protected.fscs.org.uk/what-we-cover/banks-building-societies-credit-unions/deposit-limit/
- FSCS, small businesses and limited companies: https://protected.fscs.org.uk/making-a-claim/claims-process/small-business/
- FCA, using payment service providers: https://www.fca.org.uk/consumers/using-payment-service-providers
- FCA, safeguarding requirements for payment and e-money institutions: https://www.fca.org.uk/firms/emi-payment-institutions-safeguarding-requirements
- Current Account Switch Service, business common questions: https://www.currentaccountswitch.co.uk/common-questions-business/